You did not choose GitHub

Ask a developer why their code lives on GitHub and you usually get a blank pause. Not because the answer is complicated, but because there is no answer. Nobody sat down and picked it. It was already there the day they signed up, it was where the tutorials pointed, it was where everyone else already was. GitHub is not a decision most people made. It is a default they inherited.

And here is the part that still surprises people: GitHub belongs to Microsoft. Has done since 2018. The place a whole generation of open source developers keep their work, their identity, their whole contribution history is a product owned by one of the largest closed-source companies on the planet. That is not a conspiracy, it is just a fact that the day-to-day convenience quietly sands off. Once you notice it, you cannot un-notice it.

The cracks an open source supporter cannot unsee

None of this would matter much if the platform were a good steward. That is where it gets uncomfortable.

Start with Copilot. It was trained on mountains of public open source code, much of it under licenses that ask for attribution or reciprocity, and it happily reproduces that code stripped of both. Developers sued in 2022, and while a lot of the case was thrown out, the courts let the core claims of copyright infringement and breach of license terms move forward. Read that again: your openly shared work was fed into a paid product, and the question of whether that was even legal is still live in court. That is the platform’s relationship with the community it is built on.

Then there is the direction of travel. In 2025 Microsoft folded GitHub into its new CoreAI organisation, the CEO left, and no replacement was named. GitHub is no longer even a company with its own leadership. It is a feature inside Microsoft’s AI division, and its roadmap now answers to whatever serves that division. For anyone who cared about GitHub-the-forge rather than GitHub-the-AI-funnel, that is the writing on the wall.

And the reliability is not covering for any of it. The platform has been genuinely shaky. Dozens of major outages across the last year, including a platform-wide meltdown in 2025 kicked off by a routine database migration that cascaded into everything. When the free tier of your critical infrastructure is both misaligned with your values and unreliable, the “it just works” excuse stops working.

What makes Codeberg attractive

So where do you go? For me the answer has been Codeberg, and the appeal is almost the mirror image of everything above.

It is a non-profit. A registered German association, funded by its members, with no shareholder to please and no AI product to feed. That single structural fact changes the incentives for everything downstream. Nobody is looking at your repositories wondering how to monetise them.

It runs on Forgejo, which is open source all the way down. The forge hosting your open source code is itself open source, and if Codeberg ever went a direction you disliked, you could take Forgejo and run the whole thing yourself. Try doing that with GitHub. This is the part that actually matters to an open source supporter: the tool practices what the community preaches.

Your code is not training fodder. There is no Copilot quietly ingesting public repos, no assumption that sharing openly means surrendering your work to someone else’s model. Open here means open, not open-for-harvest.

And it is not a toy. You get the things you actually use (issues, pull requests, CI through Forgejo Actions, Pages for static sites) without the sprawl of features nobody asked for. It is smaller and refreshingly boring, the way infrastructure should be.

Make it a choice this time

I am not going to pretend GitHub vanishes overnight. Its gravity is real, the ecosystem lives there, and plenty of projects genuinely need that reach. I still keep the projects that depend on the crowd where the crowd is. But everything that is actually mine now lives on Codeberg: personal work, in-house projects, the things I want on infrastructure I trust. And I sleep better for it.

The point is not that you must leave. The point is that staying should finally be a decision instead of an accident. Look at who owns the place your code lives, look at how they treat the community that fills it, and then choose on purpose. If you have never made that choice, Codeberg is the easiest possible place to start making it.